Fake and Real Education in Trading

We've heard a lot lately about fake news, both from the political right and left.  The truth is that it's difficult to report truth, objectively.  Too often agendas slant what we present, turning what should be enlightenment into persuasion or, at worst, propaganda.  A credible academic journal presents studies supporting and not supporting various ideas, allowing the data to speak for themselves as much as possible.  No one would read an academic journal that only published information supporting specific views, suppressing contrary evidence.

In trading, we see a great deal of web content, seminars, webinars, and books offered as "education".  Too often, this is fake education, in that it promotes a particular agenda that is marketed by the writer.  How often have we seen something offered as education that starts with a tease and ends with a sales pitch to get interested students to purchase a service or product?  That's an infomercial, not information.  It's not education; it's advertising.

So what is *real* trading education?

*  Real education educates.  You come away with specific information and/or skills that you didn't previously possess.  

*  Real education is on the cutting edge.  It provides new information and new skills.  It does not merely repeat what has been written many times previously.  If what you encounter in a book or webinar could have been encountered three years ago, thirteen years ago, or thirty years ago, it's rehashing, not educating.

*  Real education is grounded.  It draws upon actual research and actual practice.  It is not mere opinion or preference.

*  Real education stands on its own.  It is not a throwaway lead-in for commercial products or services.

As many of you know, I teach in a medical school.  I value the education and training of medical students and residents, and I especially respect the continuing education of practicing physicians.  Without continuing education, a physician is locked in old information and old practices and become stale.  Patients suffer.  Without quality continuing education, traders--and their capital--suffer the same fate.  Education is far too important to be left to fakery.

True continuing education for experienced traders is the next great frontier in trader development.  Not rehashings of worn out technical trading patterns, bromides about discipline, or trading tales from old timers.  Real, actionable education based on real research and real practice.  It's an important part of what distinguishes a profession from a hobby.

Further Reading:  Toward a Curriculum for Traders
.

Komentar